Contemporary reviews were generally positive and praised Davis' performance, but some found her character Julie's redemption at the end of the film to be unconvincing. The movie premiered at the
Radio City Music Hall, and
Frank S. Nugent of
The New York Times wrote that the film "would have been considerably more effective...if its heroine had remained unregenerate to the end. Miss Davis can be malignant when she chooses, and it is a shame to temper that gift for feminine spite...It is still an interesting film, though, in spite of our sniffs at its climax."
Variety reported that the film was "not without its charm" and "even completely captivating" at times, but found it detracting that the main character "suddenly metamorphoses into a figure of noble sacrifice and complete contriteness" and described the ending as "rather suspended and confusing."
The Film Daily called it "a really outstanding screen triumph for Bette Davis. She plays an emotional role that calls for running the gamut of emotions, and she handles the part with consummate artistry." ''
Harrison's Reports'' called it "Powerful dramatic entertainment...It is not what one would call cheerful entertainment, and may not appeal to the rank and file, but it should please those who like good acting."
John Mosher of
The New Yorker wrote, "Something went wrong with
Jezebel, possibly nothing more than the plot, and all its rich dressing-up can't make it alive...no scene quite comes off, and at the end, when the she-devil suddenly turns into a saint and a martyr, one isn't even interested. This
Jezebel just seems daffy." On the
review aggregator website
Rotten Tomatoes, the film holds an approval rating of 94% based on 23 reviews, with an average rating of 7.6/10.
Accolades In 2002, the film ranked 79 on
AFI's 100 Years... 100 Passions. ==See also==