Andrew ran as the NDP candidate in
Toronto—St. Paul's in the
2018 provincial election and was elected as a
member of Provincial Parliament (MPP). She was the critic for culture and women's issues and was part of the Ontario NDP Black caucus, along with fellow MPPs
Laura Mae Lindo,
Faisal Hassan,
Rima Berns-McGown and
Kevin Yarde. She is the first Black and Queer person to be elected to the Ontario Legislature. Andrew has passed several pieces of legislation, including Bill 61 which proclaims the week beginning February 1 in each year as Eating Disorders Awareness Week. Bill 61 received Royal Assent in December 2020. As of August 11, 2024, Andrew served as the Official Opposition critic for Women's Social and Economic Opportunity as well as for Culture and Heritage. She was defeated in the
2025 Ontario general election by Liberal candidate
Stephanie Smyth. ==Personal life==