McKeever played baseball "as a business" for several years for teams in the Boston area.
The Baltimore Sun reported that McKeever was working at a South Boston
foundry before signing his first professional contract with the Reds.
The Boston Globe reported that he was "a large man with no previous pro experience" who would be positioned at
catcher and serve as one half of Boston's "change battery" with pitcher
Charlie Daniels. before he was released along with
Fred Tenney in August. McKeever later played for several years for clubs in
Biddeford, Maine (1885),
Waterbury (1885),
Minneapolis (1887),
Eau Claire, Wisconsin (1887),
Easton, Pennsylvania (1888),
Haverhill, Massachusetts,
Lowell, Massachusetts, and
Oil City, Pennsylvania (1895). He also later played for the Boston-based clubs Woven Hose in 1890, the Whittentons in 1891, and Institute in 1893. He played principally at the catcher position but also appeared as a right fielder, center fielder, and first baseman. Poor health led to his retirement as a player during the 1895 season. He thereafter served as manager of a semipro team in Boston. ==Death==