Playfair became the head coach of the
Calgary Flames on July 12, 2006, a promotion from his role as an assistant coach and replacing
Darryl Sutter who previously had been both head coach and general manager. Sutter continued as general manager of the Flames. Playfair was also previously the head coach of the
Saint John Flames of the
American Hockey League, where he coached them to a
Calder Cup championship in 2001. On June 14, 2007, Playfair was replaced as head coach of the Calgary Flames by
Mike Keenan and demoted to associate coach. In his first and only season as head coach of the Flames, the team went 43–29–10 which was good enough for the eighth and final playoff spot. The team went on to be eliminated by the
Detroit Red Wings in the first round. On June 5, 2009, Playfair began his second stint as a head coach in the American Hockey League after being named the head coach of the
Abbotsford Heat (Calgary Flames affiliate). In his two seasons at the helm, Playfair led the Heat to a 77–61–9–13 record (176 points). In 2009–10, he guided the Heat to the North Division finals, falling to the
Hamilton Bulldogs in six games. On March 27, 2010, during one of the division final games against the Bulldogs, Playfair lost his temper and broke two hockey sticks due to penalty calls. Following the fame, Playfair called the owner of the Heat, the president of the Flames, and the president of the AHL to explain his actions. The league also fined him an undisclosed amount. He was hired as the associate coach of the
Arizona Coyotes on June 13, 2011. On June 27, 2017 the Coyotes and Playfair mutually parted ways. In June 2019, he was hired as an associate coach for the
Edmonton Oilers. Playfair was fired by the Oilers in February 2022, along with head coach
Dave Tippett. While serving as an associate coach for the
Prince George Cougars, Playfair was named an assistant coach for Team Canada at the
2023 Spengler Cup. ==Career statistics==