As a result of Dylan's sympathetic treatment of Gallo, critics such as
Lester Bangs harshly criticized the song upon its release. Bangs described it as "repellent romanticist bullshit". The song's legacy remains mixed: a
USA Today article ranking "all of Bob Dylan's songs" called it "forgettable" and lamented that it had replaced "
Abandoned Love" on
Desire's final track list but in a readers' poll conducted by
Mojo, "Joey" was rated the 74th most popular Bob Dylan song of all time.
Jerry Garcia, who was responsible for getting Dylan to start performing it live in 1987, considered it a "great song" and Dylan himself characterized it as "Homeric" when discussing his
Nobel Prize in Literature win with
Edna Gundersen in 2016. Critic Paul Zollo, writing in
American Songwriter magazine, called it a "beautifully detailed and cinematic" song and a "masterpiece" in 2021. ==Live performances==