Clute's first professional publication was a long science-fictional poem entitled "Carcajou Lament", which appeared in
TriQuarterly in 1959. His first short story (one of his few) was "A Man Must Die", which appeared in
New Worlds in 1966. In 1960, he served as Associate Editor of
Collage, a Chicago-based "slick" magazine which ran only two issues; it published early work by
Harlan Ellison and
R. A. Lafferty. During the 1960s and 70s he appeared chiefly in
NEW WORLDS, becoming an important contributor of essays and reviews. In 1977, Clute published his first novel,
The Disinheriting Party (
Allison & Busby). Though not explicitly a fantasy, this story of a dysfunctional family has a fantasy feel, rather like much
postmodern literature. Reviewer
Hilary Bailey wrote that this "everyday story of family life in a
revenge tragedy, of relations and revelations, hidden identities and loss of identity,
incest and inheritance, all brooded over by the Father Who Will Not Die, carries itself forward swiftly and surely to its conclusion with strength and control." Clute's second novel,
Appleseed (2001), is the story of trader Nathanael Freer, who pilots an
AI-helmed starship named
Tile Dance en route to the planet Eolhxir to deliver a shipment of nanotechnological devices. Freer meets a man calling himself Johnny Appleseed, who rejoins Freer with his lost lover, Ferocity Monthly-Niece. Meanwhile, a terrifying, data-destroying "plaque" is threatening the galaxy's civilizations. Clute has proposed it as the first novel in a trilogy. Science fiction and fantasy author
Paul Di Filippo called it "a space opera for the 21st century."
Reviewing Clute's first significant science fiction reviews appeared in the late 1960s in
New Worlds. "Prometheus Emphysema", "An empty bottle. An empty mind. An empty book", "Book of the Mouth", and "Mage Sh*t".
Excessive candour Clute has issued a
polemic he calls the "Protocol of Excessive Candour", which argues that reviewers of science fiction and fantasy must not pull punches because of friendship: His review column of this name began at
Science Fiction Weekly and moved to
Sci-Fi Wire. Writing style Contributing the essay on himself for
The Encyclopedia of Science Fiction, Clute wrote that his "criticism, despite some curiously flamboyant obscurities, remains essentially practical; it has appeared mostly in the form of reviews, some of considerable length." He told an interviewer, Matthew Davis has written, "Clute stands out, not just because of the depth and breadth of his knowledge, but also for the individuality of his writing; even the most formal sentence plucked from one of his scholastic works is readily identifiable due to his individual judgement and style." Author Henry Wessells, in a review of
The Darkening Garden, wrote: ==Critical reception==