1901 and 1902 seasons DeWitt enrolled at
Princeton University in 1900. He sustained a hand injury as a freshman that prevented him from playing football that fall. As a sophomore and junior, he was a starter for the
1901 and
1902 Princeton Tigers football teams that compiled records of 9–1–1 and 8–1 -- the only losses coming to
Yale. He played mostly at the
guard position, some at
tackle, and also earned a reputation as "the greatest drop and punt kicker in the gridiron." At the end of the 1902 season, DeWitt was selected by
Walter Camp as a first-team guard on the
1902 All-America team.
1903 season In December 1902, DeWitt was elected by his teammates as captain of the
1903 Princeton Tigers football team. At the start of the 1903 season,
The Buffalo Commercial wrote of DeWitt: "This man is rightly considered the greatest athlete in the colleges of America today. At kicking goals from the field he has probably never had an equal." He led the 1903 team to an 11–0 record, outscoring opponents 259 to 5. The 1903 team has been rated by multiple selectors (
Billingsley Report,
Helms Athletic Foundation,
Houlgate System, and
Parke H. Davis) as the national champion and as co-national champion by the
National Championship Foundation. Princeton's undefeated season hinged on the final game against rival Yale, a team Princeton had not beaten since 1899. DeWitt led the Tigers to victory, scoring all of Princeton's points in an 11–6 victory. He recovered a Yale fumble and returned it 73 yards for a touchdown in the first half. With one minute remaining and the game tied at 6–6, DeWitt kicked a game-winning goal (then worth five points) from placement from Yale's 43-yard line.
The Boston Globe described DeWitt's game-winning kick: In the long struggle which was now almost at an end, the Princeton captain had played a lion's part. He was wearing a bandage around his temple, and his right hand and wrist were wound with bandages. The black and orange jersey had been torn completely off, and the muscles of giant stood out in bold relief in the dull light of the late afternoon. A hush fell over the entire grand stand. Finally DeWitt having satisfied himself that his aim was good, swung back his right leg, and the ball shot straight as an arrow between Yale's goal post." During DeWitt's three years on Princeton's football team, the Tigers compiled a record of 28-2-1 with the only losses coming against Yale.
Walter Camp placed him on an all-time All-America team. One writer calls him Princeton's greatest football player. He was inducted into the
College Football Hall of Fame in 1954. ==Track and field==