Goddard was appointed
Officer of the Order of the British Empire (OBE) in the
1951 Birthday Honours for services to sport in Barbados. The
tour of Australia in 1951–52, however, resulted in a 4–1 win to Australia, and the 1–0 victory in the two-Test series that followed in New Zealand was insufficient compensation. Goddard made 182 runs at 26.00 and took 5 wickets at 32.20 in the six Tests he played (he stood down for the Fifth Test, allowing
Jeff Stollmeyer to captain the side – to a 202-run defeat). By this time his captaincy was beginning to arouse dissent. As Australia inched towards a one-wicket victory in the Fourth Test in Melbourne, Goddard argued on the field with Stollmeyer and
Gerry Gomez about who should bowl, and
Sonny Ramadhin, who had bowled 39 overs and taken 3 wickets, got fed up and walked off the field. After the tour, Stollmeyer, who had been Goddard's vice-captain in India, England, Australia and New Zealand, said that Goddard had received too much credit for the success of the 1950 tour, and that the other senior players of the side had received too little. His comments led to long-standing animosities and divisions in the West Indian camp. Later, when Goddard was picked to captain the team in the
tour of England in 1957, Stollmeyer quit first-class cricket for good. Goddard did not play in the home series against India in 1952–53, England in 1953–54, or Australia in 1954–55, when Stollmeyer was the captain for most of the time. He returned to the side as player-manager of the team to New Zealand in 1955–56, when
Denis Atkinson was captain and Stollmeyer did not tour. Playing in the first three Tests of the four-match series, Goddard scored 147 runs for once out, including his highest Test score of 83 not out in the Second Test at Christchurch, when he added 143 for the seventh wicket with Atkinson after West Indies had been 169 for 6. West Indies won all three Tests, then lost the Fourth, in which Goddard did not play. The 1957 tour to England resulted in a 3–0 defeat in the five-match series. Goddard himself made only 112 runs at 16.00 and took 2 wickets at 64.00. His resolute defence helped the team draw the First and Third Tests. In the Third, West Indies followed on 247 runs behind and were 194 for 6 when Goddard came to the wicket, and he made 61 in 215 minutes in a partnership of 154 with
Collie Smith that left England too little time to score the winning runs. His final tally from 22 Tests as captain was eight wins, seven losses and seven draws. Apart from his captaincy and his batting and bowling, he was also a fine fielder close to the wicket, "notably at silly mid-off". ==Later life==