Brooklyn Dodgers In 1932, Karcis signed with the
Brooklyn Dodgers of the
National Football League (NFL). He spent four years with the Dodgers from 1932 to 1935, appearing in 42 games, 30 as a starter. Karcis was told by a doctor that he would not play football again. The Pirates had compiled losing records in each of their prior seasons. The 1936 team, with Karcis at fullback, compiled a 6–6 record and finished second in the NFL's Eastern Division. Karcis played for Pittsburgh from 1936 until 1938. After the Pirates lost three straight games to open the 1938 season, head coach
Johnny "Blood" McNally decided to release Karcis, who was being paid the thenn-hefty sum of $485 per game. Rather than tell Karcis to his face, Blood arranged for Karcis to be given the wrong departure time for the team's train to an exhibition game in Boston. When Karcis arrived at the station, the train carrying the team had already left. Karcis called the team's offices and was told that Blood had released him.
New York Giants After his release by the Pirates, Karcis signed with the Patterson Panthers, a minor league club, for $50 per game. Karcis was then signed by the
New York Giants on October 5, 1938. After losing two of their first three games, the Giants with Karcis in the lineup did not lose another game and won the NFL championship. In Karcis' home debut as a Giant, he recovered a Philadelphia fumble and returned it 77 yards for a touchdown and also set up the Giants' second touchdown. Karcis scored five touchdowns and tallied 181 rushing yards for the 1938 Giants. ==Coaching career==