After graduating from
Stow-Munroe Falls High School in 2001, Magaro went on to study theater at
Point Park University in
Pittsburgh. Among his acting highlights are
The Big Short,
Past Lives and
Carol (2015). His early film work included
The Brave One, the
HBO film
Taking Chance and a lead role in the
horror film My Soul to Take. Magaro also appeared in eleven episodes of
Orange Is the New Black, spanning seasons 3-7. In 2008, Magaro starred in the popular Walmart x Coke holiday commercial, which played in movie theaters across the country. One of Magaro's earliest appearances was as an extra in Steven Spielberg’s 2005 film
Munich; he revisited the events of the
1972 Summer Olympics in 2024's
September 5. Magaro was the lead in the 2012 film
Not Fade Away, which earned him the HFF Spotlight award. In 2019, he portrayed the lead role of "Cookie" in Kelly Reichardt’s critically acclaimed film
First Cow, for which he was nominated for a
2020 Gotham Award as Best Actor. ==Personal life==