watershed On June 6, 1862, following the
First Battle of Memphis, the United States recaptured Memphis from the Confederacy. On June 11, 1862, while inebriated, John Forrest shot a
master's mate of the named Theodore S. Gillmore while both were present at a facility operated by
sex worker Puss Pettus on Main Street in Memphis. According to a reporter from St. Louis, the two men not had not otherwise been interacting until Forrest "pointed at his uniform and said 'That is all the advantage you have over me'" and then shot Gillmore in the side. Forrest was arrested and taken aboard the
Carondolet after the shooting. Per the
Chattanooga Rebel, "After having been kept in irons for several weeks, he was put into a wooden box, but little longer than his body, bored with holes, barely sufficient to admit the necessary are to sustain life. In this condition he was transferred to the most heated part of one of their gunboats, lying opposite the city, where he was fed on bread and water and steamed to the utmost extent of his endurance." According to the
Memphis Daily Union Appeal of July 4, "The United States naval officer who was shot by John Forrest, has expressed, in epistolary form, a strong desire to have him released from confinement, saying, that he forgave him, freely and pitied him much for his ill health and other infirmities." Forrest was eventually transferred to the city jail. Bedford Forrest biographer
John Allan Wyeth, who had served in Gen. Forrest's brigade as a young teenager, described a similar incident under the heading "John Forrest, Wounded in the Mexican War and Partially Paralyzed, Shoots a Federal Major in Memphis in 1864." This account conflicts on significant detail of
motive and
fight choreography when compared with to story outlined in contemporaneous newspaper articles. In Wyeth's account, Forrest used crutches as a result of being shot "through the lower part of the spinal cord" during the Mexican War. In 1862 he was living at the
Worsham House hotel. After a U.S. Army officer insulted his mother during a visit to her plantation outside of Memphis, per Wyeth: According to Wyeth, Colonel Forrest later successfully demanded John Forrest's release and the younger brother was not convicted of any crime. An account collected in the 1920s from local informants in
Grenada, Mississippi also seemingly describes Forrest's captivity on the
Carondelet: "The Yankees captured John Forrest, Nathan Bedford Forrest's brother, and placed him beside a boiler on a gunboat and burned him because he was N. B. Forrest's brother. This made N. B. Forrest very bitter. John Forrest had to use crutches after that." A history of the
Carondelet lists Gillmore as a crewman and describes his participation in the
Battle of Island Number Ten but makes no mention of John N. Forrest. According to a history of the sex commerce of 19th-century Memphis, on June 14, 1862, three days after the shooting, "the police shuttered a
brothel kept by Puss Pettus...Pettus defiantly reopened her establishment, but the
provost marshal closed it permanently a week later." == Marriage, death, burial, estate ==