Internal channels In Fall 2013 and February 2014, Tye attended two classified
National Security Agency briefings on
Executive Order 12333, which was signed by President
Ronald Reagan and amended by President
George W. Bush. Tye attended these briefings so that he could help prepare the State Department's response to the high-profile leaks disclosed by NSA whistleblower
Edward Snowden. Radack's other clients,
Thomas Drake and
William Binney had also raised concerns about EO 12333 through internal channels prior to 2010. Following a January 17, 2014 speech by President
Barack Obama on NSA surveillance reforms that failed to mention changes to activities under E.O. 12333, Tye began to use internal channels at the State Department to press his concerns over the order. Tye maintains that he has not, and will not, release any classified information. Prior to publication, he submitted his
Post editorial for approval by the State Department and the NSA, which both deemed that no changes were necessary. Joel emphasized that Americans cannot be directly targeted under Executive Order 12333, and that use and retention of the collected data is limited by policies approved by the
U.S. Attorney General. Notably, under these policies, data cannot be retained for more than five years. Tye's own attorney,
Mark Zaid, a critic of Snowden, acknowledged that Snowden's disclosures had likely made it easier for Tye to come forward with his own revelation. ==Whistleblower Aid==