20th Century Fox and Columbia Pictures After an unsuccessful
screen test directed by
Fred Zinnemann for his film
Teresa (1951), Wagner was represented by
Albert R. Broccoli. He made his uncredited film debut in
The Happy Years (1950), was signed by agent
Henry Willson and put under contract with
20th Century Fox. "I started off as an
ingenu", he said. "I was 19 years old. I was the boy next door. But you always felt you could work your way up, that you could have a better part in the next picture. [Head of Fox] Darryl Zanuck was always placing me in different positions." ''
Let's Make It Legal'' (1951) was a comedy where Wagner again supported an older star, in this case
Claudette Colbert. Wagner first gained significant attention with a small, showy part as a
shell-shocked soldier in
With a Song in My Heart (1952). with Wagner in
Broken Lance (1954) Also popular was a Western,
Broken Lance (1954), where Wagner supported
Spencer Tracy for director
Edward Dmytryk, appearing as Tracy's son. Fox gave Wagner the lead in an expensive spectacular,
Prince Valiant (1954). While popular, critical reception was poor and Wagner later joked his wig in the movie made him look like
Jane Wyman. He was teamed with Jeffrey Hunter in a Western,
White Feather (1955). Wagner supported
Robert Mitchum in a Korean War movie,
The Hunters (1958), and appeared with a number of Fox contractees in a World War II drama,
In Love and War (1958). After a cameo in
Mardi Gras (1958), Wagner supported
Bing Crosby and
Debbie Reynolds in
Say One for Me (1959). Trying to kick-start his career, Wagner appeared with his then-wife Natalie Wood in
All the Fine Young Cannibals (1960), made for MGM. In January 1961, Wagner and Wood formed their own company, Rona Productions, named after the first two letters of both their first names. Rona signed a three-picture deal with Columbia pictures for Wagner's services, which was to start with
Sail a Crooked Ship (1961) and
The Interns. He also had a deal to make one more film at Fox, which was to be
Solo, the story of a jazz drummer directed by
Dick Powell, or
The Comancheros with Gary Cooper. Wagner made
Sail a Crooked Ship but his part in
The Interns went to James MacArthur.
Solo was never made, and
The Comancheros was made instead with John Wayne and Stuart Whitman. Wagner did make
The War Lover (1962) with
Steve McQueen, which was filmed in England.
Return to Hollywood and Universal Pictures On Wagner's return to America he started playing in a theatre for the first time with the lead role in
Mister Roberts for one week at a holiday resort just outside Chicago. The disciplines of the theatre did not interest him and Wagner expressed glee to be back in Hollywood and find a supporting role in the modern-day private investigator hit,
Harper (1966), starring
Paul Newman. Wagner signed with
Universal Pictures in 1966, starring opposite his future wife
Jill St. John in the films
How I Spent My Summer Vacation, a made-for-TV movie released in the United Kingdom as
Deadly Roulette, and
Banning (1967). He returned to Italy to make a caper film with
Raquel Welch for MGM,
The Biggest Bundle of Them All (1968).
Television star In 1967,
Lew Wasserman of Universal convinced Wagner to make his television series debut in
It Takes a Thief (1968–1970) on ABC-TV. "I was opposed to doing
Thief", Wagner said later. "But Lew Wasserman said: 'I want you to be in TV Guide every week. This is your medium, you've got to try it, you'll be great.' Roland Kibbee wrote the part for me, and I would have missed all that if I hadn't listened to Lew." While the success of
The Pink Panther and
Harper began Wagner's comeback, the successful two-and-a-half seasons of his first TV series completed it. In this series, he acted with
Fred Astaire, who played his father. Wagner was a longtime friend of Astaire, having gone to school with Astaire's eldest son, Peter. Wagner's performance would earn him an Emmy nomination for Best TV Actor. He was a regular in the
BBC/Universal World War II prisoner-of-war drama
Colditz (1972–1974) for much of its run. He reunited with McQueen, along with
Paul Newman and
Faye Dunaway, in the
disaster film The Towering Inferno released in the same year. It was a massive hit, although Wagner's part was relatively small. Only one reached the screen, the very successful TV series ''
Charlie's Angels'', for which Wagner and Wood had a 50% share, though Wagner was to spend many years in court arguing with Spelling and Goldberg over what was defined as profit. Wagner and Wood acted with
Laurence Olivier in
Cat on a Hot Tin Roof (1976), as part of Olivier's television series
Laurence Olivier Presents for the UK's
Granada Television. Wagner had a small role in some all-star Universal films,
Midway (1976) and ''
The Concorde... Airport '79'' (1979).
Hart to Hart Wagner's most successful series was
Hart to Hart, which co-starred
Stefanie Powers and Lionel Stander and was broadcast on ABC-TV from 1979 to 1984. No one else was seriously considered for the role.
George Hamilton had a high-profile at the time and was suggested, but producer
Aaron Spelling said that if he was cast "the audience will resent him as Hart for being that rich. But no one will begrudge RJ [Wagner] a nickel." During the series run, Wagner reprised his old Pink Panther role in
Curse of the Pink Panther (1983). He also had a supporting role in
I Am the Cheese (1983). Wagner played an insurance investigator in the short-lived TV series
Lime Street (1985). In 1985, he reflected, "Bad-guy roles work if they're really good parts, but they don't come along very often. I think that what I've been doing has worked for me. Sure I'd like to do a Clint Eastwood, grizzled, down-and-out guy, but there aren't many scripts like that... What has been projected for me is an international quality that can take me anywhere and get me into all kind of involvements; to do otherwise would mean a character role."
Later career Wagner appeared in a TV movie with
Audrey Hepburn,
Love Among Thieves (1987) and in a miniseries with
Jaclyn Smith,
Windmills of the Gods (1988). He and St. John worked with
Pierce Brosnan in the miniseries remake of
Around the World in 80 Days (1989). For
Tom Mankiewicz, he played a supporting part in
Delirious (1991). More widely seen was
Dragon: The Bruce Lee Story (1993), where Wagner played a producer. Wagner played
Love Letters on stage with Stefanie Powers. They also reprised their Hart characters in a series of TV movies. Wagner's film career received a boost after his role in the
Austin Powers series of spy spoofs starring
Mike Myers. Wagner played
Dr. Evil's henchman Number 2 in all three films:
Austin Powers: International Man of Mystery (1997),
Austin Powers: The Spy Who Shagged Me (1999) and
Austin Powers in Goldmember (2002). He also had small roles in
Wild Things (1998),
Crazy in Alabama (1999),
Play It to the Bone (2000),
Becoming Dick (2001) and
Sol Goode (2001). Wagner hosted
Fox Movie Channel's
Hour of Stars, featuring original television episodes of
The 20th Century Fox Hour (1955), a series in which he had appeared in his early days at the studio. In 2005, he became television spokesman for the Senior Lending Network, a
reverse mortgage lender and in 2010 began serving as spokesman for the Guardian First Funding Group, another reverse mortgage lender. In June 2011, Guardian First Funding was acquired by Urban Financial Group, who continued to use Wagner as their spokesperson. In 2007, Wagner had a role in the BBC/AMC series
Hustle. In season four's premiere, Wagner played a crooked Texan being taken for half a million dollars. As Wagner is considered "a suave icon of American caper television, including
It Takes a Thief and
Hart to Hart",
Robert Glenister (
Hustles
fixer,
Ash Morgan) commented that "to have one of the icons of that period involved is a great bonus for all of us". Wagner also played the pivotal role of President
James A. Garfield in the comedy/horror film
Netherbeast Incorporated (2007). The role was written with Wagner in mind. He had a recurring role of a rich suitor to the main characters' mother on the sitcom
Two and a Half Men. His final appearances on the show were in May 2008. Wagner has guest-starred in 13 episodes of
NCIS as Anthony DiNozzo Sr., the father of
Anthony DiNozzo Jr., played by
Michael Weatherly. Weatherly had previously appeared as Wagner in the TV movie
The Mystery of Natalie Wood. Wagner was set to star as Charlie in the 2011 remake of ''
Charlie's Angels'', but he had to exit the project due to scheduling conflicts. Despite his apparent feeling of distaste when he was working with Raquel Welch on
The Biggest Bundle of Them All, they reunited 50 years later on the 2017 Canadian series
Date My Dad. == Personal life ==