In 1792, Dragging Canoe died suddenly on March 1, 1792, but he had earlier said he wanted Watts to succeed him. Watts, was then living again in the Overhill area. He became war council head, or "
skiagusta," of the Lower Cherokee.
First actions Watts, along with Bloody Fellow, Doublehead, and "Young Dragging Canoe" (
Tsula), continued to encourage Indian unity in resistance to European-American settlers. He honored the agreement with McGillivray, of the Upper Muscogee, to build blockhouses (from which warriors of both tribes could operate) at Running Water, Tennessee,
Muscle Shoals in Alabama and at the junction of the Tennessee and
Clinch rivers near Kingston, Tennessee. Watts also traveled to
Pensacola to conclude a treaty with the
Spanish governor of
West Florida,
Arturo O'Neill. Under that treaty, the Spanish would provide arms and supplies to the Native Americans to carry on their war against the U.S. At about this time, Watts moved his base of operations to
Willstown (Cherokee town), in what is now Alabama. This put the Cherokee closer to their Muscogee allies while shielding them from the westward expansion of the new
United States. In September 1792, Watts assembled a large gathering of Cherokee and Muscogee warriors (which included some cavalry). He planned to lead a campaign into the
Cumberland region of
Appalachia. It was to be a three-pronged attack:
Tahlonteeskee (aka
Ataluntiski) would lead a force to ambush the Kentucky road; Middle Striker would take the Walton road; and Watts would lead the main army of 280 Cherokee, Shawnee, and Muscogee warriors against
Nashville (it was then the capital of the Miro District of the new
Southwest Territory). On the way to Nashville, the army encountered and attacked a settlement known as
Buchanan's Station but suffered serious casualties. Watts was seriously wounded, and
Siksika (known as "The Shawnee Warrior," and an older brother of
Tecumseh));
Tahlonteeskee (also called
Talotiskee of the Broken Arrow, a Muscogee warrior); Little Owl (a brother of Dragging Canoe); and Pumpkin Boy (a brother of Doublehead), all died in the encounter.
Last campaign Later in 1793, Watts sent envoys to Knoxville, which was at the time the capital of the
Southwest Territory, to meet with Governor
Blount to discuss terms for a lasting peace. The peace party included Bob McLemore,
Tahlonteeskee, Captain Charley of Running Water, and Doublehead, as well as the white delegates. Along the way, the group was attacked by a militant group of frontiersmen during a stop at the Overhill town of Coyatee.
Hanging Maw was wounded, while his wife and daughter (along with several other Indians and one of the white delegates), were killed. The Cherokee people, along with Watts' Chickmauga warriors, agreed to await the outcome of the subsequent trial. In large part because the man responsible, COL. James Herrell Hubbert (who had lost his family in an Indian raid) was a close friend of John Sevier, the trial proved to be a farce. Watts responded by leading an invasion of the Holston area with more than 1,000 Cherokee, Muscogee, and Shawnee warriors—one of the largest Native forces seen in the region. His target was Knoxville. Along the way, Cherokee leaders debated whether to kill all the settlers or only the men. Doublehead argued for killing everyone, while
James Vann supported sparing the women and children. On the way to Knoxville, the war party encountered the small settlement of
Cavett's Station. After they had surrounded the place,
Bob Benge negotiated with the inhabitants, agreeing that if they surrendered, their lives would be spared. However, after the settlers had walked out, Doublehead's group and his Muscogee allies attacked and killed them. Vann grabbed one small boy and pulled him onto his saddle, but Doublehead killed the boy with an axe. Watts intervened and saved another young boy, handing him to Vann, who put the boy behind him on his horse and later handed him over to three of the Muscogee for safe-keeping. One of the Muscogee killed and scalped the boy a few days later. == Final peace ==