A constitutional initiative passed in the 2004 election required, for the first time, that candidates run as a team. In the primary election, Vice President
Elias Chin and Senator
Alan Seid finished first with 3,027 votes while Toribiong and his vice presidential candidate Delegate
Kerai Mariur took 2,526 votes. Senate president
Surangel Whipps, Jr. and Billy Kuartei finished third with 2,248 votes and Senator
Joshua Koshiba and Peleliu Governor
Jackson Ngiraingas finished fourth with 1,387 votes. In the runoff election, Toribiong and Mariur were victorious with 5,040 votes to Chin-Seid's 4,828. Toribiong and Mariur were inaugurated on January 15, 2009. He accepted six Uyghur former prisoners from the
Guantanamo Bay detention camp, which became controversial due to their inability to assimilate into Palauan society. In 2012, Toribiong was challenged for reelection by his predecessor,
Tommy Remengesau Jr. and by former vice president
Sandra Pierantozzi. In the runoff, Remengesau defeated Toribiong 58%-42%. Toribiong left office on January 17, 2013. ==Post-presidency==