Upon release, the album was well received by reviewers.
Sounds gave
Join Hands a grade of 4.5 out of 5, with the reviewer, Peter Silverton, noting a change in the sound: "The mix is different to the last album. Now there's a clarity which frames Sue's voice like it was a thing of treasure". Similarly,
Paul Morley wrote in
NME that "Side one's five songs... are all addictive Banshees mini-dramas". Ronnie Gurr, a
Record Mirror reviewer, also hailed the record, saying: "Poppy Day establishes the band's perfect employ of atmospherics and sets the tone of all the tracks". "Mother" was compared to the soundtrack of an
Alfred Hitchcock film, with Gurr noting that the "track features a musical box, echoes menacing guitar grumblings and Siouxsie providing vocals that would befit any of Hitchcock's best matricides". Gurr concluded that with "Severin's truly disturbing scratchings",
Join Hands was a dangerous work that "should be heard". The
Huddersfield Daily Examiner called
Join Hands "a superb album of strength and poetry," and praised "that weird and wonderfully controlled voice of Siouxsie". In a retrospective review published in 1989, Steve Lamacq wrote in
NME that
Join Hands was "a more absorbing, haunting LP" than the band's debut album. Lamacq rated it 8 out of 10, though he said that the version of "The Lord's Prayer" was "out of place". The 2004 edition of
The Rolling Stone Album Guide gave a 2.5 out 5 rating and commented that the "brooding trance music" of their previous material "can slip into dankness" on
Join Hands.
AllMusic's David Cleary considered "Icon" the best track on the album, commenting that it "survives an unpromising beginning to open out into a faster main section with fuller vocal sound and gutsier guitar work", but Cleary panned the rest of
Join Hands, describing it as "almost uniformly grim, with dragging tempos, bleak lyrics, long and wandering free-form structures, static and often unfocused harmony and thick, colorless arrangements". == Legacy ==