Ponticelli began his career for
Hinckley Leicester Road. Ponticelli made his professional debut in a 3–1 EFL Cup loss to
Blackburn Rovers on 8 August 2017. Ponticelli made his
Football League debut as a substitute in the 85th minute of a 0–0 draw against
Barnet on 7 October 2017. In August 2018, Jordan joined
EFL League Two side
Macclesfield Town on a season-long loan deal. The loan was terminated in January 2019. On 10 July 2019, Ponticelli went out on loan again, this time joining
League One club
Tranmere Rovers on a six-month loan deal. Ponticelli dropped down two divisions for his next loan, signing for
National League club
Wrexham on 22 January 2020 until the end of the 2019–20 season. Ponticelli joined Wrexham in a permanent deal in August 2020. Ponticelli was released at the end of the
2021–22 season. In July 2022, Ponticelli joined
National League North club
King's Lynn Town following their relegation. Ponticelli was released from
King's Lynn Town at the end of the
2023–24 season. In September 2024, Ponticelli joined
Southern League Premier Division club
Halesowen Town On December 13 2024, Ponticelli signed for
National League club
Tamworth. On February 26 2026, Ponticelli joined
Halesowen Town F.C. of the Southern League on loan. ==Career statistics==