San Diego Padres Eichelberger was selected by the
San Diego Padres in the first round of the 1975 January secondary phase of the MLB draft. Playing
Single-A ball that year with
Reno, he saw early success, going 10–4 with a 2.77
earned run average (ERA), In
Triple-A in 1978, he had an 8–13 record and a 4.50 ERA along with two
shutouts for
Hawaii. In 156
innings pitched, he led the
Pacific Coast League (PCL) with 113
walks. He was
called up to the major leagues in September, making his debut with three
relief appearances for San Diego that month. In 1979, Eichelberger thought he had a good
spring training with the Padres, allowing two runs in 12 innings, and was disappointed when he was sent down to Hawaii. considered a hitter's league, when he was promoted to San Diego. In his second major league start on September 21, he threw a complete game and allowed just four
hits in a 3–1 victory over the
Los Angeles Dodgers, earning his first
win in the majors. He was 1–1 with a 3.43 ERA in three starts for the Padres, and might have had another win were it not for a
fielding error against
San Francisco on September 29. Eichelberger expected to stick with the Padres in
1980, but he began the season with Hawaii again. He was 7–3 with a 3.51 ERA and leading the PCL in strikeouts in June, when he was recalled by San Diego to replace an injured
Randy Jones. On July 13, he pitched 10 innings and threw 150
pitches in an eventual 4–3 win over the Dodgers in 15 innings. He made 13 starts for the Padres and finished 4–2 with a 3.64 ERA. Eichelberger spent his first full season in the majors in
1981 and developed into a solid starter, On May 12, he recorded his first major league shutout and did not walk a batter in a 3–0 win over the
New York Mets. Eichelberger was named the
Padres' Opening Day starting pitcher for
1982. On June 2 against the
Chicago Cubs, Eichelberger almost threw the Padres' first
no-hitter. A questionable call by the
official scorer to not charge an error resulted in
Scot Thompson being credited with a second-inning
single on a
ground ball that was not cleanly fielded by
Tim Flannery. Eichelberger kept the Cubs hitless over the next seven innings and ended up with a
one-hitter, the eighth in San Diego history. The Padres won the game 3–1. On the
road against San Francisco on June 25, he allowed two runs in innings for his first win since the one-hitter. Eichelberger, who was
batting .111 at the time, hit a game-winning
double in the seventh inning after asking Padres manager
Dick Williams not to
pinch hit for him despite a 2–2 tie with two
outs and a
runner on
third base. In July, Eichelberger was demoted to the
bullpen after struggling with a 6–9 record and 4.25 ERA, surrendering 18
home runs in 129 innings. He was replaced in the rotation by rookie
Andy Hawkins, who had been called up from the minors. In his first relief appearance, Eichelberger injured his shoulder. By August, fellow veteran starters
John Curtis and
Chris Welsh were also demoted to the bullpen, with rookies
Dave Dravecky and
Eric Show joining Hawkins in the rotation. Eichelberger returned on August 9 against
Houston, pitching two innings in relief, where Williams said he would remain in the interim. Eichelberger returned to a starting role on September 1, pitching a complete game in a 4–1 win over
Pittsburg. He finished the year 7–14 with a 4.20 ERA and eight complete games. Over five seasons in the majors with San Diego, Eichelberger was 20–25 with an ERA of 3.88. He struggled with his control, striking out 212 with 214 walks in 431 innings.
Cleveland Indians Indians general manager
Phil Seghi had long been interested in Eichelberger. "He has a great arm. Something could click for him and he could become a big winner", Seghi said. Cleveland manager
Mike Ferraro said that he had "a great fastball. His problem is consistency, but the raw talent is there." After a number of fine starts, he entered his June 15 matchup against the
New York Yankees with a 3–3 record and an ERA of 2.89. The Indians lost the game 8–5, setting off a six-game stretch in which he was 0–6 with a 12.60 ERA, prompting Ferraro to again switch Eichelberger's and Heaton's duties. On July 18, Eichelberger fell to 3–10 after surrendering five runs, including two
unearned, in innings against the
Chicago White Sox, during an emergency start in place of
Bert Blyleven. Six weeks passed until his next start on August 27, when he allowed four runs and three walks in two innings in a 6–3 loss to
Seattle, his eighth consecutive loss as a starter. Eichelberger ended the season 4–11 with a 4.90 ERA, going 2–8 with a 6.33 ERA over the last four months. In
1984, he was 0–1 with 7.04 ERA in innings in spring training. He was cut by Cleveland, in favor of pitcher
Ernie Camacho, in their final roster move before the start of the season. The Indians owed Eichelberger $300,000 for the remaining year of his two-year guaranteed contract. Manager
Pat Corrales said that Seghi and
Gabe Paul of the front office preferred Eichelberger due to his experience.
Atlanta Braves Eichelberger signed with the
Milwaukee Brewers in late April 1984, and returned to the minor leagues for the first time since 1980. He began poorly with their Triple-A
Vancouver team, which Eichelberger attributed to not having played in April. He was 8–11 with a 4.96 ERA for Vancouver when they released him in August. After pitching in seven games with a 4.07 ERA, Eichelberger was released, partly due to a conflict with player-pitching coach Torrez. he was 4–1 with a 3.00 ERA in 21 innings when he broke his finger while
bunting on July 31, ending his season. He began 1986 with Richmond, but received limited work, and was sent down to Double-A
Greenville for 38 days before being recalled to Triple-A. Eichelberger was switched back to a starter in 1987, and finished the season 7–5 with a 3.38 ERA. He also pitched well in the
Venezuela winter league with
Lara, going 5–4 with a 2.20 ERA. Eichelberger was re-signed by Atlanta for the
1988 season.
The Atlanta Constitution called him an "unlikely but strong candidate to make the staff next season as a long reliever". He was one of 24 pitchers that they invited to spring training. At the time, only eight of the pitchers had thrown more than 100 innings in the majors, The Braves had the worst pitching staff in the
National League in
1987, and were looking to fill out their staff while allowing their young prospects to develop in Triple-A. After beginning the season with Richmond, Eichelberger was 0–2 with a 4.82 ERA when he was called up on April 29, 1988, the culmination of four years in the minors and a three-year journey since he was released by Single-A Miami on May 15, 1985. He was added to the bullpen and assumed the role of the team's 10th pitcher, replacing prospect
Gary Eave, who returned to Richmond to play regularly.
Japan and SPBA Eichelberger played in Japan in 1989, joining
Larry Parrish on the
Yakult Swallows of the
Pacific League as their two foreign players allowed on each team. In 1989–90, Eichelberger played in the
SPBA's inaugural season. He was 11–5 with a 2.90 ERA and 70 strikeouts for the
West Palm Beach Tropics, who were the Southern Division champions and finished with the league's best record. He was named the starting pitcher on the SPBA All-Star first team, and finished third in voting for the league's
most valuable player, won by his teammate
Ron Washington. Their manager, Eichelberger's former Padres manager Dick Williams, was voted the SPBA Manager of the Year. He spent spring training with the
Milwaukee Brewers in 1990 before being cut. Later that year, he played with the SPBA's
Sun City team, ==Player profile==