The partnership between Benson and Sanderson dates back to 2006, when Benson produced
Three Days Grace's triple-platinum sophomore album
One-X., which would go on to become their most commercially successful album to date, featuring the hit singles "Animal I Have Become", "Pain", "Riot", and "Never Too Late". Benson later produced the band's follow-ups
Life Starts Now,
Outsider,
Explosions, and
Alienation. In an interview with
Grammy.com, Benson stated that the idea for launching the label stemmed from his desire for greater creative and commercial control over projects he produced, citing frustration with traditional royalty structures and project outcomes. Benson and Sanderson first signed singer
Diamante to a production deal and self-financed her record after she was dropped by her previous label; that collaboration's success ultimately led to the formation of
Judge & Jury Records in 2021. The company achieved early recognition with the release of
Waiting on the Sky to Change, a collaboration between
Starset and
Breaking Benjamin, which reached No. 1 on the Mediabase Active Rock chart in 2022. Since then, the label's roster has expanded to include artists such as
Saliva,
Butcher Babies, and
Alien Ant Farm, among others. == Operations ==