The magazine
Pon Manam mentioned that the film is a different triangular love story and appreciated the directorial skill of M. K. I. Sukumaran, while the weekly
Suspense mentioned it as a new presentation in triangular love stories and will succeed at the box office without any doubt.
Maalai Malar acknowledged the director saying, M. K. I. Sukumaran deserves a place along with
Bharathiraja,
K. Balachander and
Mani Ratnam, while
Kumudam weekly praised actor Shankar, but criticised the climax of the film.
Marumanam praised the acting skills of the lead actors along with
Balan K. Nair summering it as a very different film.
Top Star magazine praised the film mentioning that "youth will enjoy the film".
Sihappu Naada weekly praised the director and mentioned "Kadhal Enum Nadhiyinile is a must watch for lovers, failed lovers, successful lovers and couples who loves after marriage".
The Hindu wrote that the film will make the younger elements to think twice before getting involved in serious love affairs that may have far reaching consequences is told with conviction and a certain amount of farsightedness.
Dinamani said that the film will be much loved by college students.
Ananda Vikatan wrote that, even though the film is a love triangle, the director has presented it in a unique way without the usual cliches of caste and status in society and gave 42/100 marks.
Thaai weekly praised the film for its unusual presentation of a love triangle and mentioned actor Shankar's successful re-entry after
Oru Thalai Ragam. Mounam Ravi of
Dina Sari appreciated the director M. K. I. Sukumaran for presenting a strong love story, saying that he is the true successor to his guru
Mahendran Ramji from
Makkal Kural wrote that the film is a treat for Lovers and will haunt the minds for the tragic end.
Dina Dhooth recommended this film for college students and appreciated the director.
Moon magazine mentioned that the film is a treat for youngsters. N. Krishnaswamy of
The Indian Express wrote, "I suspect director M. K. I. Sukumaran messed up the script because he wanted Sankar's role to be different from the one he played in
Oru Thalai Raagam." == References ==