Publishers Weekly gave the novel a starred review, calling it a "mesmerizing debut". The review states that "readers familiar with the source text will be wowed by Patel’s reimagining, while those new to the story will be won over by its powerful, multilayered heroine and epic scope." A review in
Kirkus Reviews writes that the author "recasts the
Ramayana as a power struggle between women who want to participate in politics and public service and men who would rather they stay home." The review concludes that "With spellbinding twists and turns, this is a political novel and very much a feminist one." Elizabeth Hand of the
Washington Post describes the original Kaikeyi as a member of "the pantheon of wicked stepmothers — an unsavory roster from which she’s rescued" by Patel's novel. Hand praises the novel as a feminist tale, a "careful depiction of one woman’s struggle to bring justice to an unjust world". Preeti Hay of
India Currents praised the novel's complex characterizations, writing that "the relationship between Rama and Lakshmana, and between Sita and Rama is not idyllic as we are used to believing. Like any good fictional story, Patel’s novel is full of conflict and flaw." Hay concludes that the novel is "a fierce and compelling story of a woman whose voice has finally been dared to be imagined." Saloni Sharma of
Scroll.in praised the narrative, writing that the novel is "a defiant act of reclamation, [which] rescues the eponymous queen from eternal erasure and allows her to tell her own story." She notes that the novel might offend religious sensitivities, stating that "
Kaikeyi is likely to be a contentious book. It is certainly not going to go down well with anyone who sees the Ramayana as a religious text and its hero as sacrosanct." Sharma writes about the history of the
Ramayana and its numerous different versions, referencing the text
Three Hundred Ramayanas by
A. K. Ramanujan. For Sharma, "
Kaikeyi then, is not so much a radical departure as the continuation of a dialogue." Lacy Baugher Milas of
Paste also praised the novel's characterization, especially the "rich" relationship between Kaikeyi and Rama, as well as their personality clashes. She also praises Kaikeyi as a tragic figure. Milas writes that Kaikeyi's use of the Binding Plane to control others may be "uncomfortable and problematic", but "even Kaikeyi’s worst actions, in this retelling, can almost always be traced back to her desire for agency..." In a more negative review, Mahvesh Murad of
Reactor criticized Kaikeyi's use of the Binding Plane to manipulate others. The review states that "In trying to absolve a character vilified in canon, Patel has given us a confused narrative, in which Kaikeyi the character remains destructive, but all her actions are constantly justified as having noble intent." ==References==