Initially, the scholarly debate on the issue of the Livonian werewolf was restricted to scholars in the German-speaking world, and it did not appear in English-language overviews of European werewolf beliefs like
Montague Summers'
The Werewolf (1933). According to Dutch historian Willem de Blécourt, Thiess' case was first brought to the attention of English-speaking scholars by the German anthropologist
Hans Peter Duerr (1943–) in his book
Dreamtime: Concerning the Boundary between Wilderness and Civilization (1978, English translation 1985). Duerr briefly discussed the Livonian werewolf in a chapter of
Dreamtime entitled "Wild Women and Werewolves" in which he dealt with various European folk traditions in which individuals broke social taboos and made mischief in public, arguing that they represented a battle between the forces of chaos and order.
Carlo Ginzburg The Italian historian
Carlo Ginzburg (1939–) discussed the case of the Livonian werewolf in his book
The Night Battles: Witchcraft and Agrarian Cults in the Sixteenth and Seventeenth Centuries (1966, English translation 1983).
The Night Battles was devoted primarily to a study of the
benandanti folk tradition of early modern
Friuli in northeastern Italy, in which local Friulians fell into trance states in which they believed that their spirits left their bodies to battle malevolent witches, in doing so protecting their crops from famine. Ginzburg believed that there were definite similarities between the
benandanti and the case of Thiess, noting that both contained "battles waged by means of sticks and blows, enacted on certain nights to secure the fertility of fields, minutely and concretely described." In Ginzburg's view both the
benandanti tradition and Thiess's werewolf tradition represented surviving remnants of a shamanistic substratum that had survived Christianization. In his 1992 paper on the life and work of Ginzburg, the historian John Martin of
Trinity University in
San Antonio, Texas expressed his support for Ginzburg's hypothesis, claiming that Thiess' role was "almost identical" to that of the
benandanti. In a similarly supportive vein, the Hungarian historian
Éva Pócs noted the existence of "werewolf magicians" who were aligned to "European shamanistic magicians" in a paper on Hungarian
táltos. Other academics were more cautious than Ginzburg in directly equating the Livonian werewolf with shamanism. Dutch historian Willem de Blécourt noted that in
Dreamtime, the German anthropologist Hans Peter Duerr had refrained from making an explicit link between shamans and werewolves, although he did acknowledge the similarities between Thiess and the
benandanti. ==References==