Fimleikafélag Hafnarfjarðar In March 2021, Talbert signed with her first professional club,
FHingar, the
women's football department of the
Fimleikafélag Hafnarfjarðar multi-sport club. The team finished the season 11–3–4 with Talbert recording 46 saves in goal. After playing for FHingar, Talbert trained with the
West Ham United women in London from September to December 2021.
Benfica In January 2022, Talbert joined
Sport Lisboa e Benfica, commonly known as Benfica, a Portuguese
women's football team based in
Lisbon that plays in the
Campeonato Nacional Feminino. In her year and a half at Benfica, she played in 23 matches and won two
Campeonato Nacional Feminino titles, the League Cup (
Taça da Liga Feminina), and the Portuguese Super Cup (
Supertaça de Portugal Feminina). Talbert was elected by the Players Union as the best goalkeeper of the 2021–22
Liga BPI. Her contract ended with
Sport Lisboa e Benfica, on June 30, 2023.
West Ham United In August 2023, Talbert signed with
West Ham United Women Football Club, an English
women's football club affiliated with
West Ham United. The club plays in the
Women's Super League, the top tier of
English women's football. Talbert was immediately sent out on loan to Swedish side
Djurgårdens IF in a bid to accumulate the points needed to meet Governing Body Endorsements [GBE] requirements for the International Sportsperson visa. She made nine appearances for the club in the
Damallsvenskan, helping The Blue Stripes to avoid an end of season relegation play-off. In June 2024, Talbert was transferred back to West Ham United. She was loaned out to
Aston Villa in January 2025 and made her debut as a second-half substitute for
Sabrina D'Angelo on March 2, 2025, during a 2–0 loss against Everton at
Villa Park.
Calgary Wild FC In January 2026, she signed with Canadian
Northern Super League club
Calgary Wild FC, with Talbert saying of the move “The opportunity to be part of a new professional league in Canada and contribute to building a strong, competitive team really aligns with my love for growth, competition, and inspiring the next generation of women in soccer.” == Career statistics ==