From 2011 to 2017 Lewek sang
Handel's
Messiah with the
Oratorio Society of New York at
Carnegie Hall. During those years, she also performed both
Mozart's and
Verdi's
Requiems, as well as
Mass in B minor and
Christmas Oratorio by
Johann Sebastian Bach. In 2013, regarding her
Carnegie Hall debut in Handel’s
Messiah, Corinna da Fonseca-Wollheim of
The New York Times praised her “Communicative verve and thrilling beauty.” She also commented on her rendition of “Rejoice greatly, O daughter of Zion,” especially the tempo and embellishment choices, describing ‘He shall speak peace’ as “lovingly ornamenting the cadence in a way that was both original and entirely subservient to the music.” She was advised not to sing the Queen of the Night in
The Magic Flute, yet Lewek has performed the role hundreds of times in the finest opera houses in Europe and the United States, She has sung at
Aix-en-Provence and in
Barcelona. Since 2013, Lewek has performed Queen of the Night in
The Magic Flute at the
Metropolitan Opera every season. The same year, she was scheduled to perform Cunegonde in
Leonard Bernstein's
Candide with
Washington National Opera but pulled out due to pregnancy and was replaced by
Emily Pogorelc. In 2019, Lewek accused critics of insulting her figure, who called her body shape "buxom" and "stocky". In 2024 Kathryn Lewek starred as Olympia, Antonia, and Giulietta in the Salzburg Festival production of The Tales of Hoffmann. ==References==