After his senior year of high school, Reynolds received offers from Navy,
Air Force, and
Wofford. Eventually, he committed to Navy, being impressed by the school's campus and football record.
2012 season Reynolds started his freshman season at the
United States Naval Academy as the fourth-string
quarterback, seeing minor action limited to
garbage time. In the fourth game of the season against Air Force, starting quarterback Trey Miller injured his ankle and Reynolds took over, leading the
Midshipmen to the win. Afterwards, Reynolds was named the starter,
2013 season In
2013 against
San Jose State, Reynolds scored seven rushing
touchdowns, the most by a quarterback in
NCAA history. Navy finished the season 9–4 and won the
Armed Forces Bowl against the
Middle Tennessee Blue Raiders.
2014 season Reynolds started eleven games in
2014. Against
Temple, Reynolds twisted his knee and missed the game against
Texas State. The 8–5 Midshipmen ended the season with a 17–16 win over the
San Diego State Aztecs in the
Poinsettia Bowl.
2015 season In the
2015 game against
SMU, Reynolds broke the record for the most career rushing touchdowns in
FBS history with 78, passing
Montee Ball. Later in the season in the
Army–Navy Game, Reynolds surpassed
Adrian N. Peterson's record for the most rushing touchdowns in
NCAA Division I history with 85. He later broke the record for most career total touchdowns with 88 and most rushing yards by a quarterback with 4,559. Reynolds also holds other quarterbacking records including the most career rushing attempts and touchdowns, most rushing touchdowns and most rushing touchdowns in a game. He is also the only Navy QB to go 4–0 against
Army. Reynolds finished fifth in the
Heisman Trophy running, the highest by a service academy player since Navy quarterback
Roger Staubach's win in 1963. The 11–2 Midshipmen ended the season with a win over the
Pittsburgh Panthers in the
Military Bowl, winning 44–28 at home in their own stadium. With this win, Reynolds helped contribute to the first Navy team to ever achieve 11 wins in a season. Also, Reynolds and his senior class picked up their 36th win, which tied the Midshipmen class of 1909. Reynolds later played in the
2016 East–West Shrine Game, an annual all-star game for seniors, where he made the East team upon switching from quarterback to
running back. Even though he did not play in the game due to tightness in his back, he was made a unanimous captain for the East team. Moreover, during the East–West Shrine Game, Reynolds won the
Pat Tillman Award, which "is presented to a player who best exemplifies character, intelligence, sportsmanship, and service. The award is about a student-athlete's achievements and conduct, both on and off the field." On February 28, 2016, the Naval Academy announced that Reynolds would be the last player to wear Number 19. Reynolds joins the list of
Roger Staubach (No. 12),
Joe Bellino (No. 27), and
Napoleon McCallum (No. 30) whose numbers have been retired by the academy.
Statistics Source: ==Professional career==