Vitaphone labeled the finished film an "Old Timers" comedy. Audiences loved it, as reported by theater managers. "Believe it or not, this is the first time our house has roared with laughter over a two-reel comedy in years, Old Timers, come again with another one." "If you haven't shown this one already, by all means do so! If the pie-slinging sequence doesn't bring tears of laughter to your eyes, laughing pains to your stomach, and plenty of shoulder vibration, then you had better pay a visit to your nearest psychiatrist." "The old Keystone Cops in a pie-throwing contest. House in an uproar." Although the stars of
Keystone Hotel were no longer available for new films, Warner Bros. went ahead with silent-comedy revivals anyway. The studio consulted its backlog of Mack Sennett silent comedies and compiled them as new two-reel subjects with wisecracking narration, usually voiced by Lou Mercelle or
Knox Manning. This series of six shorts ran from 1939 to 1945, beginning with a two-reel condensation of the Ben Turpin feature
A Small Town Idol. The others were ''Love's Intrigue
, Happy Faces
, Wedding Yells
, Happy Times and Jolly Moments,
and Good Old Corn
. The series continued as "Vitaphone Novelties" (now one reel each, ending with Here We Go Again
in 1953). Many of these Warner shorts included footage from Keystone Hotel'', without the soundtrack, as exhibits of "authentic" Keystone comedy. Warner Bros. reissued
Keystone Hotel to theaters in 1947 with a new title sequence and an updated musical score. The 1947 edition was first reprinted for television in 1957, and was edited into a one-reel, silent 8mm home movie in 1967. The 1947 reissue is the version that has aired on
Turner Classic Movies. ==References==