There was little playing opportunities for women players aside from college but Wyant played in several USASA Women's National Amateur Cup competitions with the Orlando Buddies & Excel teams throughout the late 1980s and '90s. The team's best results were in 1995 with a run all the way to the semi-final match vs the Long Island Lady Riders (0–1 defeat). Ironically, Wyant was 'duel carded' that year, playing with her Orlando Club team in the USASA Cup Competition, thus playing against her Long Island Lady Riders teammates whom she was carded with in the United Soccer League USISLW-League. in 1994 Wyant joined the Orlando Lions in the very first (unofficial) season for the USISLW-league launched by Franciso Marcos United Soccer Leagues. The league consisted of 12 teams. The USISLW-League extended Wyant's playing career and went on to become the premier playing league for women until the launch of the WUSA professional league in 2002. In 1995 she joined the
Long Island Lady Riders where she spent nine seasons, and played 8,636 career minutes in over 99 games. As a leader in defense on the team, she helped Long Island to the
United Soccer Leagues (USL)
W-League National Championships in
1995. She suffered a season ending injury during the 1996 season, but returned for the 1997 season fully healthy leading the teams to a second National Championship defeating the Chicago Cobras in a thrilling eight round shootout. In 1999 the Long Island Lady Riders hosted the
Brazilian Women's National Team for an International Friendly as the Brazilians were preparing for the 1999 Women's World Cup upsetting the powerhouse 2–0. Shortly after announcing her retirement in August 2003, Wyant was named the General Manager for the Lady Riders. Prior to her promotion, Kim implemented the team's very successful camps and youth academy. Under her direction the Lady Riders twice-received the USL W-League ‘Organization of the Year’ awarded annually to the top USL organization displaying excellence both on and off the field. Wyant also served as the team interim coach during the last quarter of the team's 2002 season. In 2004, Wyant was inducted into the
United Soccer League's Soccer Hall of Fame., the second female player to be inducted by the United Soccer League. ==Managerial career ==