Time listed it among their 100 Must-Read Books of 2025. It was featured on
Amazon's Best Books of 2025. It was nominated for a
Goodreads Choice Award in the categories of Readers' Favorite Mystery & Thriller and Readers' Favorite Audiobook. It was also nominated for a
Barry Award for Best Mystery. It was longlisted for a
PEN/Faulkner Award for Fiction and an
Aspen Words Literary Prize. The audiobook was nominated for an
ITW Thriller Award for Best Audiobook and an
Audie Award for Audiobook of the Year.
Kirkus Reviews called the novel "tense" and praised its "lofty" philosophizing for "freshening the genre", but stated that the plot "sometimes wobbles" with the romance between Roman and Torrent's half-sister.
Publishers Weekly called Roman's transition into becoming an aspiring crime boss "almost too smooth", his growing appetite for violence "overplayed and undermotivated", and the novel's
nihilism "more suffocating than powerful", but praised its "evocative" scene-setting and its "richly detailed" portraits of rural black family life.
Neely Tucker of
The Washington Post called the novel as "dark, riveting and accomplished" as Turnbull's previous works, but said that the Black Baron Boys were not "that interesting" and called Dante "irritating".
Chanelle Benz called the novel "propulsive" and "powerful" in her review for
The New York Times, praising how Turnbull "flawlessly" conjures Jefferson Run as a poverty-stricken Southern city and calling Roman "a character of Shakespearean proportions".
Roxane Gay gave it a four star review on
Goodreads, calling it "one hell of a thrilling read", but noted that a few elements felt "a bit repetitive". Former
Amazon editor Vanessa Cronin called it "riveting", and described Cosby as "one of the greatest American crime writers ever to do it." == References ==