Critical reception In France Upon its release in France on ,
Kirikou and the Men and the Women received generally positive reviews from critics. While the graphics, animation, and soundtrack were unanimously praised, there were sometimes differing opinions about
Michel Ocelot's ability to renew himself in this third film focused on
Kirikou. The visual universe, animation, and music were still appreciated:
Le Parisien described the film as
an animation, graphics, and music still as enchanting, while
Ouest-France said it was
beautiful work, accomplished and delicate. The specialized cinema magazine Positif noted that The rhythm, the golden colors of Kirikou's universe suit this filmmaker (Michel Ocelot) wonderfully, in an expression of fullness that warms the heart
. Ouest-France
and Le Monde appreciated the use of 3D to create depth effects on several planes rather than volume, a technique already employed by the director in his previous film, Tales of the Night''. The five stories are mostly considered successful, though not without some differences of opinion. According to Noémie Luciani from
Le Monde, Arnaud Schwartz finds the five stories
still as delightful, with increasing intensity throughout the film and stressing the themes of welcoming the stranger and the transmission through storytelling. Some critics, however, were more skeptical: in
Télérama, Cécile Mury thinks that
even the most ardent Kirikou
fan might find some rather trivial stories a bit long, while Romain Blondeau, in
Les Inrockuptibles, finds that
Michel Ocelot chain together five generally uninspired nursery rhymes with no narrative link or sense of rhythm. The ability of this third installment to renew the Kirikou universe has elicited mixed reviews. The daily newspaper
Le Monde is convinced. and
Ouest-France, Pamela Pianezza believes that
If Ocelot gives in to the easy route by chaining stories rather than focusing on narrating a unique adventure (as in his superb Azur and Asmar
), he nevertheless confirms his exceptional storytelling talent. Les Inrockuptibles, In
Le Soir, Fabienne Bradfer argues that despite the 3D, the beauty of the graphics and the lovely humanistic message, this third film
lacks creativity and succumbs to commercial easiness in
Le Soir on October 24, 2012. ==Accolades==