During his college years, Reynish also played with
Bakersfield Brigade in the
USL Premier Development League. Reynish was selected in the fourth round, 43rd overall, of the
2007 MLS Supplemental Draft by
Real Salt Lake on January 18, 2007. Reynish played for RSL in friendlies against the
Fiji national football team, the
China national football team, and English side
Everton, as well as in the
MLS Reserve Division, but did not make his senior debut until May 2, 2009, when he came on as a substitute for an injured
Nick Rimando in a game against
Colorado Rapids, two years and four months after being signed. During 2010 Reynish was loaned to
USL Second Division side
Charleston Battery, and played three games for them during their USL2 Championship-winning season. Reynish was released by Salt Lake on December 3, 2012. He entered the
2012 MLS Re-Entry Draft and became a free agent after going undrafted in both rounds of the draft. Reynish signed with
North American Soccer League side
New York Cosmos for the fall season. He helped the club capture the
2013 Fall Championship and
Soccer Bowl 2013 titles. He was named the best goalkeeper for the 2013 season, winning the NASL Golden Glove award. Reynish re-joined Major League Soccer in January 2014 when he signed with
Chicago Fire. He made one regular season start for Chicago during the 2014 season. On January 20, 2015, Reynish was traded to
New York Red Bulls for a
2016 MLS SuperDraft pick. Reynish was loaned to affiliate side
New York Red Bulls II and made his debut as a starter for the side on April 4, 2015, helping the club to its first victory, a 4–1 result over
Toronto FC II. Reynish was traded by New York to expansion side
Atlanta United FC in exchange for a fourth-round pick in the
2018 MLS SuperDraft on March 1, 2017. Reynish signed with
USL side
Fresno FC on March 12, 2018, for the 2018 season. Reynish announced his retirement from playing professional soccer at the end of the 2018 USL season. ==Awards and honors==