In early 1954, it was announced that Maureen O'Hara would star in the film based on a script by Oscar Brodney produced by Robert Arthur. It was made at Universal, where O'Hara had a one-film-a-year contract. The script was described as "semi-historical".
Lex Barker was reportedly going to play the male lead but O'Hara objected, claiming audiences would only see him as Tarzan.
Jeff Chandler was signed instead.
Victor McLaglen joined the cast as Chandler's helper. Shortly before filming began, however, Chandler was replaced by a Universal contractee,
George Nader. Chandler was still making
Foxfire which would finish only a day before
Godiva was scheduled to start and wanted a break. Nader had previously replaced Chandler on
Five Rivers to Cross after the star was suspended by the studio due to a contract dispute.
Arthur Lubin was assigned to direct. He said he did not want to but the studio would put him under suspension if he refused. He later called it "a bad picture". Filming started on 30 August 1954. Rex Reason joined the cast. He had previously been acting for Universal under the name "Bart Roberts" but for this film the studio allowed him to use his real name. Maureen O'Hara filmed the famous ride wearing a
leotard, with her long hair covering the rest of her body. Arthur Lubin said he was inspired by the painting by
Landseer. The sequence was shot on a closed set. ==Reception==