Early inhabitants Boggy Island was an autonomous black Seminole village that was settled by Central African slaves from
Kongo. Black Seminoles settled near the Boggy Island area of Lake Panasoffkee around 1813 and named it Sitarkey's Village after Sitarkey, an Alachua Seminole who had settled in the area. Nearby laid the areas of Gum Slough and Indian Mound Springs. The Seminoles used the Lake Panasoffkee area to hold councils and
Green Corn Dances. The black Seminoles raised corn, rice, and sugar cane which Dexter gave them in 1822. They also possibly planted one of the oldest orange groves in Florida.
Second Seminole War Generally, the Sitakey's Village area was untouched during the Second Seminole War, On January 10, 1837, General Thomas Sidney Jesup, looking for Osceola, raided the village. Osceola and three warriors fled. Jesup captured 16 black Seminoles while the rest of the village escaped. In all, Osceola, 50 warriors, and their families left for the headwaters of the
Ocklawaha River. Twelve days later, Jesup led his troops from
Fort Armstrong to the Ocklawaha River.
Modern town According to Broward Mill, the past president of the Sumter County Historical Society, Lake Panasoffkee from the time that Sumter County was settled by whites until damaging freezes which wiped out the area's citrus industry in the 1880s and 1890s. Charles G. King, a
Cleveland entrepreneur, bought 2,500 acres (square kilometers) in Lake Panasoffkee and developed 737 acres (square kilometers) into Monarch Grove in 1908. An oak hammock on the property was left undisturbed. King and his employees used the sour oranges planted by the Seminoles for orange stock. In 1926, the grove produced about 40,000 boxes of oranges.
Lake Panasoffkee dredging According to
Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation commissioners Bob Wattendorf and Marty Hale, Lake Panasoffkee had 15 fish camps and was considered to be one of the state's best places to fish. In 1981, water levels in Lake Panasoffkee dropped to levels that had not been seen since 1962, the year the Wysong Dam was built. Southwest Florida Water Management District officials discussed the construction of a temporary dam to elevate water levels. Lake Panasoffkee residents believed that the Wysong Dam contributed to the destruction of the
Withlacoochee River.
Little Miss Lake Panasoffkee case On February 19, 1971, two hitchhikers from
Illinois discovered the partially decomposed body of an unidentified young woman between the ages of 17 and 24 years old under the northbound lane of Lake Panasoffkee's
Interstate 75 overpass. She was found with a man's belt around her neck. Sumter County authorities named her "Little Miss Lake Panasoffkee" and buried her in the Oak Grove Cemetery in
Wildwood. The sheriff's department made several attempts to identify the woman. possibly hailing from the town of
Lavrion (located 60 miles (96 kilometers) southeast of
Athens). The victim is believed to have moved to the United States between one and three months prior to her murder. The new information contradicted the Sumter County Sheriff's Department's initial assumption that the Jane Doe was either white or Native American; they had created composite sketches reflecting those ethnicities. Sumter County authorities determined, based on the time of her death, that she was possibly visiting the
Tarpon Springs area for the celebration of
Epiphany on January 6, 1971. In 2025, she was identified as 21-year-old Maureen Rowan (). ==Geography==