Virginia Tech Nolley was forced to sit out his freshman season due to the NCAA reviewing his academic eligibility. While he sat on the bench, Virginia Tech finished 26–9 and reached the Sweet 16 of the NCAA Tournament. After the season, the Hokies' top five scorers and coach
Buzz Williams departed, but Nolley announced he was staying at Virginia Tech and had no intention of transferring. Nolley scored 30 points including four three-pointers in his debut for the Hokies, a 67–60 win over
Clemson. After scoring 27 points against
Lehigh and 23 points against
USC Upstate, Nolley was named
Atlantic Coast Conference freshman of the week on November 18, 2019. He had 22 points in a 71–66 upset of number 3-ranked
Michigan State on November 25, hitting a crucial three-pointer with under a minute to go. At the conclusion of the regular season, Nolley was selected to the ACC All-Freshman Team and was Honorable Mention All-Conference. He averaged 15.5 points and 5.8 rebounds per game. After the season, he announced he was transferring from Virginia Tech.
Memphis On April 20, 2020, Nolley announced on Twitter that he would continue his career at
Memphis, choosing the Tigers over
Georgia and
Ole Miss. Nolley was granted a waiver for immediate eligibility on August 27, 2020. He averaged 13.1 points, 4.1 rebounds and 1.8 assists per game as a redshirt sophomore. Nolley was named MVP of the NIT, helping the Tigers win the championship. The following year, Nolley was fourth for the Tigers in scoring, averaging 9.8 PPG, and helped lead the team to their first NCAA appearance since 2014. After the season, Nolley entered the transfer portal.
Cincinnati After having visits to
NC State and
Texas A&M, Nolley committed to
Cincinnati on April 27, 2022. Nolley lead the Bearcats in scoring during the
2022-23 season, averaging 16.8 PPG and 5.8 RPG. Nolley was a key contributor to the Bearcats season, earning First-Team All-
AAC honors, and would help lead the Bearcats to the Quarterfinals of the
2023 National Invitation Tournament. ==Professional career==