Marshall was subject to intense political criticism throughout his leadership of CSIRO: When he was announced as CEO, he was asked about his inspiration for innovation, and cited the lengths farmers go to for water, including
dowsing : "When I see that as a scientist, it makes me question, 'is there instrumentality that we could create that would enable a machine to find that water?"
Australian Skeptics awarded him
Bent Spoon award for "the most preposterous piece of paranormal or pseudoscientific piffle". In 2016, CSIRO deployed a water detection device as described by Marshall, and mapped underground aquifers, but the Australian Skeptics refused to withdraw their award. His narrowing of CSIRO’s focus required a 350 person reduction, including 60 climate scientists which drew intense criticism from scientists and the
Australian Labor Party, and
Greens, including: 3,000 signature petition from scientists across 60 countries 7 senate hearings Editorial in the
New York Times titled “
Australia turns its back on climate science” 50+ articles by Peter Hannam criticizing the changes 2016 election promise by
Labor to reverse Marshall’s changes Intense Public criticism of Marshall by famous scientists John Church, Tony Haymet, Andy Pitman, and Senators
Kim Carr,
Janet Rice,
Whish-Wilson said his
position was "
untenable", "
his strategy failed", and he was "
going down in flames". It was later shown that Marshall did not cut funding to climate science, but government cut $20M of funding before Marshall arrived. Despite the initial redundancies, Marshall grew CSIRO by 1,000 people, its first growth in 30y. In the midst of climate criticism, media reported he was being sued by angry shareholders in Arasor, which he had left 10y earlier. Marshall took Arasor public in 2006, and exceeded revenue expectations in 2006 and 2007, He left in 2007 and 5 years later in 2011 all the Directors were named in a speculative lawsuit launched by a
litigation fund International Litigation Partners. In a failed claim it had been alleged that Arasor's Directors produced misleading prospectuses. The case gained notoriety when it failed to show misstatements and was rejected, but then plead market based causation which does not require either damages or specific misstatements. The case was closed in 2018 with no actions against any director, but one of the plaintiffs was subsequently sued over "inflated claims". International Litigation Partners was itself sued by the
Australian Tax Office for tax evasion, and its founder Paul Lindholm charged with resisting arrest. ==References==