The night of the murder 32-year-old Tim Bosma was a Canadian from
Ancaster, a community within the city of
Hamilton, Ontario. Bosma had not previously known Millard or Smich. The pair contacted Bosma by phone to arrange a
test drive of a pickup truck he had been selling online on
Kijiji. Millard and Smich arrived on foot for the test drive just after 9:20pm on May 6, 2013, telling Bosma's wife Sharlene they had been dropped off by a friend. Bosma told his wife he would be right back, but none of the three men returned. After several hours, Sharlene contacted police to report her husband
missing. During the test drive, Bosma was shot and killed. It is unclear whether it was Smich or Millard who ultimately pulled the trigger. Bosma's body was incinerated that night at the Millard hangar.
Investigation The
Hamilton Police Service treated the Bosma case as "a missing persons investigation with unusual circumstances". They conducted a
ground search of the area around Bosma's home with the assistance of a
canine unit and local
search and rescue, and held a
press briefing on May 7. Police quickly discovered that the phone used to contact Bosma had been a
burner phone. On May 9, Bosma's deactivated cell phone was found in an industrial area on the west side of nearby
Brantford. Using the call records from the burner phone, police discovered that the men had arranged two other test drives in similar vehicles in the days preceding Bosma's murder. The two failed to arrive on time for the first, so it never occurred. The pair took the second vehicle on a test drive in Toronto on May 5. The men from that test drive matched the descriptions of the pair who had left with Bosma. One of the men carried a small satchel bag and had a tattoo on his wrist of the word "ambition" inside a box, a detail the police released to the public hoping for an identification. On May 10, police from
Peel and Toronto advised the Hamilton police about a Toronto man named Dellen Millard, who was known to carry a satchel bag and had an "ambition" tattoo on his wrist. On May 11, Dellen Millard was arrested. On May 12, Bosma's truck was found inside a trailer in the driveway of Millard's mother's home. The trailer was registered to Millardair. Police publicly confirmed that Bosma was deceased on May 14. Burned remains believed to be Bosma's had been located inside the incinerator, which had been found at Millard's farm in Ayr. Following approximately a week of surveillance, Smich was arrested on May 22.
Trial At trial, Smich, Millard, and the
Crown all presented different theories of what happened on the night of Bosma's murder. Smich and Millard each attempted to blame the other for the shooting. Smich contended that he was actually in a separate vehicle following behind Bosma and Millard, testifying that Millard shot Bosma while they were together in Bosma's truck. The Crown contended that both Smich and Millard were in the vehicle and participated in the killing. The Crown never definitively proved which of the men fired the gun. As long as both had participated in the planning and execution of the crime, both could be charged with first-degree murder regardless of who actually pulled the trigger. == Murder of Laura Babcock ==