Fodor's has described Lauretta Jean's as a "foodie icon" of Portland.
Portland Monthly included the business in a 2012 overview of the city's best biscuits. Alex Frane included the business in the magazine's 2025 list of the city's best pies, writing, "There's no denying that this tiny shop on SE Division Street makes the best pie in Portland, as indicated by the daily lines out the door". In 2013, Martin Cizmar of
Willamette Week called Lauretta Jean's "a perfect pie shop". The business ranked first in the Best Pie category in the newspaper's annual "Best of Portland" readers' poll in 2016. It won in the Best Pie Shop category in 2020. Andrea Damewood of
Willamette Week called the business Portland's best pie shop in 2023. In 2016, readers of
The Oregonian ranked Lauretta Jean's one of Portland's ten best pie shops. The newspaper's Samantha Bakall also included the bakery in 2017 list of the city's best dessert spots for
Valentine's Day. Jagger Blaec of the
Portland Mercury said "every option on Lauretta's menu is as unique as the next" in 2017. Michelle Lopez included Lauretta Jean's in
Eater Portland's 2018 list of fifteen "Portland biscuits that would make any Southerner proud", and Nick Townsend included the bakery in the website's 2020 list of fifteen restaurants "worth visiting" on Southeast Division Street. The website's 2021 overview of "legit pies" in Portland said Lauretta Jean's is "easily one of the city's top three pie shops" and complimented McMillen, who "particularly shines with her cream pies, as well as the standout salted honey pie". Oscar Ponteri included the shop in
The Franklin Post 2022 overview of Portland's best pies. Writing for
The New York Times, Jamie Cattanach said the salted honey pie "will make you understand why there's a line". Emily Hunt selected Lauretta Jean's to represent Oregon in
Tasting Table's 2026 overview of the best pies in each U.S. state. ==See also==