In 1657 the Southwicks were jailed for hosting two visiting Quaker preachers, John Copeland and
Christopher Holder. Lawrence Southwick was found to be a member of the First Church of Salem and was released to be dealt with by the leaders of that church. Cassandra remained in jail for seven weeks and was fined forty shillings for possessing a paper written by their two visitors. The paper was considered heretical by Governor
John Endicott and others. In 1658 the couple and their son Josiah were jailed for 20 weeks for being Quakers. In 1659 the two youngest of the Southwick's children, a daughter named
Provided Southwick and a son named
Daniel Southwick, were sentenced to be sold as slaves in
Barbados for unpaid fines - fines related to their being Quakers. The sentence was not carried out and they went to
Shelter Island, New York together. In 1660 Lawrence and Cassandra died within three days of each other, on Shelter Island, due to privation, starvation and exposure. ==Royal Southwick==