In the early 1960s, a confrontation broke out in the ROCOR between supporters of Archbishop
John (Maximovich) and supporters of Archbishop
Nikon (Rklitsky), who were considered as the most likely candidates for the First Hierarch position. The conflict was fueled by 2 different visions of the ROCOR mission: the supporters of St. John saw the ROCOR open to everyone and were ready in some cases to sacrifice the rite and calendar, while the representatives of the opposite party were inclined to see the ROCOR as a structure whose main task was to preserve Russian traditions. The views on church administration also differed: St. John and his supporters saw
sobornost as a living, functioning basis of church existence, while the supporters of Archbishop Nikon actually acted as defenders of the pre-revolutionary Synodal system, which in the conditions of emigration meant the dictate of the office of the Holy Synod. On February 7, 1964, Metropolitan Anastasius announced his desire to retire due to his old age and state of health. The real purpose of such a departure was the desire to control the election of his successor, with the help of his authority to prevent shocks, conflicts and possible division within ROCOR. On May 27, 1964, at the Bishops' Council, 90-year-old Metropolitan
Anastasius (Gribanovsky) retires. The votes cast for Archbishop John and for Archbishop Nikon were divided almost equally. None of the parties wanted to concede. To get out of a difficult situation, the First Hierarch advised the bishops to elect a "neutral" bishop who does not belong to any of the church parties and preferably a young one. The most suitable candidate was the youngest bishop by ordination — Bishop Philaret of Brisbane, whose candidacy was proposed by Archbishop John. In order to avoid a split, he stated that he would withdraw his candidacy if the majority voted for Bishop Philaret. Archbishops Nikon (Rklitsky) and Averky (Taushev) did the same. At the end of the voting, Metropolitan Anastasius was asked either to approve the election of Bishop Philaret, or to remain in office. The Metropolitan rejected the second proposal and agreed with the Council's decision to elect a new First Hierarch. On May 31, 1964, in the Synodal Cathedral Church the Sign, his introduction took place. After the Liturgy with the participation of all hierarchs, a white klobuk/cowl was placed on Metropolitan Philaret, and Archbishop John (Maximovich) of San Francisco, as the oldest hierarch, handed him an episcopal staff, and a second panagia was placed on Metropolitan Anastasius. Metropolitan Philaret served as the first hierarch of the ROCOR for twenty one years. He reposed on November 21, 1985 at his home in Manhattan, and was buried in the cemetery of the Church of Dormition. In November 1998, the Synod decided to transfer Metropolitan Philaret's
relics to a new vault under the
altar of Holy Trinity Cathedral at Jordanville, New York. When his tomb was opened, his relics were found to be
incorrupt. == Canonizations ==