Bing made effort to have
Artistic Japan widely reviewed. It received positive reviews throughout the West, as far away as Scandinavia and the US. The London-based periodical
The Academy praised its first issue's "attractiveness". The American
The Critic rated it "among the highest class of art-journal". The established reputations of the contributing writers to which Bing had access contributed to the magazine's quick acceptance as an authority. The vogue for Japanese art had reached a peak by the time the magazine appeared. French artist and collector of Japanese art
George Auriol expressed hope that the magazine would rekindle an appreciation of its true aesthetic qualities in the face of its brimming commercialization. The
Japan Weekly Mail newspaper ran regular denigrating reviews of the magazine's reproduction and writing quality and Bing's understanding of Japanese history and society. The magazine benefited Bing as a dealer, as prices for Japanese artworks rose with awareness of their value; this was one aim of Bing's, and he attracted some criticism for it. The magazine's reproductions served as models to Western graphic designers.
Gabriel P. Weisberg has asserted that
Artistic Japan was a major force in solidifying the valued position Japanese art was to have in the West. The aesthetic quality of the magazine itself won lasting recognition; in 1906
Gustav Klimt obtained a complete run. ==References==