The Monthly Film Bulletin wrote: "There is no doubt that
Lease of Life has its heart in the right place; and the director works hard, too, to establish the Yorkshire village atmosphere. Those with Anglican nostalgias to be satisfied will find some compensation in the church and cathedral interiors, hymns, bells, and parish comings-and-goings. The background, indeed, is more successful than the foreground, for Eric Ambler's screenplay disappoints with its sketchy characterisation and failure to make the humdrum seem anything except humdrum. Vera Thorne, for instance, is not sufficiently developed as a character for her dilemma – the ' borrowing" of the £100 – to make any impact. ... The daughter, as played by Adrienne Corri, is an unlikely figure, and her scenes with Blake the organist are rather embarrassingly novelettish in the writing. One can see, in the basic situation, possible material for a regional slice of life; but the daily round, the common task, need to be transfigured by imagination to make them interesting, and mere plotting – the vicar's illness, Mrs. Thorne's lapse – is no substitute for this. As the vicar, Robert Donat gives an earnest, careful, rather theatrically shaded performance." Upon the film's American release, critic
Bosley Crowther of
The New York Times praised Robert Donat's performance but was disappointed with the script: "It is a role charged with selfless devotion to others and to a high ideal, and Mr. Donat imbues it with such fervor and gentle sincerity as to recall his touching performance of the old teacher at an English boys' school. There is about his dying parson an air of fine genteel poverty and quiet decay. Mr. Donat makes the gallant preacher a man to be pitied and admired. However, we fear that
Eric Ambler, who wrote the script, has let him down toward the end and permitted the quality of his character to be rather cheaply compromised. ... Mr. Ambler has compelled him to give in to a shabby dodge to save his foolish wife from shame. And he has come to this wretched embarrassment through the melodramatic device of some 'borrowed' money. The whole thing goes fuzzy and quixotic—somewhat like the parson himself—toward the end. It is not a satisfactory climax for a sentimental drama that Mr. Ambler has contrived."
Leslie Halliwell said: "Somewhat depressing but well-acted drama with excellent village atmosphere."'''''''''' The
Radio Times Guide to Films gave the film 3/5 stars, writing: "Thriller specialist Eric Ambler makes a mawkish mess of what is essentially a domestic drama but through the gentle fidelity of his performance, Donat creates a decent and dignified character." In
British Sound Films David Quinlan called the film a "sincere, quiet, close-to-dull drama.'' == Awards ==