Stagger Lee has become an
archetype with some black people who admire the gangster type; a parallel to the glorification of the outlaw by a section of mainstream society. In this variation, he is the embodiment of a tough black man; one who is sly, streetwise, cool, lawless, amoral, potentially violent, and who defies
white authority. Within thirty years of Shelton's death,
Benjamin Botkin records stories among the superstitious of his having been born with a
caul over his face (signifying one with the power to see spirits and destined for trouble), or of having sold his soul to the Devil (in exchange for the hat, said to be magic, over which he killed Billy Lyons). Additional fantastic legends credit him with the ability to transform himself into animals, of having caused the
San Francisco earthquake, and of having fought a duel with
Jesse James. Author and music critic
Greil Marcus explicitly ties the Stagger Lee archetype to
Sly Stone and his album ''
There's a Riot Goin' On in his book Mystery Train: Images of America in Rock 'n' Roll Music.'' From 1982 to 1984, two masked
professional wrestlers were billed as Stagger Lee in the Southern US; Sylvester Ritter, better known as
Junkyard Dog, played him first in
Mid-South Wrestling and James Ware, who became
Koko B. Ware, followed suit in the
Continental Wrestling Association. Dallas Theater Center in Dallas produced an original musical with an adaptation of the folklore around Stagger Lee and Billy Lyons. The characters explore African American history in the Northern United States, and experience racism and violence throughout multiple cities. It opened January 21, 2015 and featured Brandon Gill, J. Bernard Calloway, Tiffany Mann, Cedric Neal, and Saycon Sengbloh.
Damon Runyon references the song in his 1920’s short story "Broadway Financier", where the song is called 'Stacker Lee.' In 2006,
Image Comics published the graphic novel
Stagger Lee, written by
Derek McCulloch and illustrated by Shepherd Hendrix, examining the historical murder of Lyons by Shelton, and the folklore that came out of it, in the framing setting of a fictionalized version of the African-American community in Saint Louis.
HarperCollins published "A Lush and Seething Hell" by
John Horner Jacobs in 2019. Consisting of two novellas, the latter – "My Heart Struck Sorrow" – focuses in large part on a horrific mystery connected to varied
acetate recordings made in the 1930s as well as the folklore surrounding "Stagger Lee". ==See also==