A draft paper discussing issues of climate sensitivity and uncertainties in the
IPCC Fourth and
Fifth Assessment Reports in relation to a recent paper by Otto et al. was submitted by Bengtsson and colleagues to
Environmental Research Letters in February 2014, and was rejected in mid March after
peer review by two referees who found that it did not meet the requirement to "significantly advance knowledge of the field". Following this, Bengtsson and his co-authors then requested the journal to publish it as a shorter "Perspective" article, but in early April the journal's editorial board turned this request down, adding that the paper contained errors and exceeded the normal size limit for "Perspective" pieces. They suggested that the errors should be corrected and a full-length paper resubmitted with a new analysis of the data. The journal said they reject 65–70 percent of papers submitted. The publishers, the
Institute of Physics, stated that the paper "which was the subject of this morning's front page story of
The Times, contained errors, in our view did not provide a significant advancement in the field, and therefore could not be published in the journal." They said that "The comments taken from the referee reports were taken out of context and therefore, in the interests of transparency, we have worked with the reviewers to make the full reports available", and put online the referee reports from mid March when the paper had been rejected. Later that day, Bengtsson issued a statement that "I do not believe there is any systematic 'cover-up' of scientific evidence on climate change or that academics' work is being 'deliberately suppressed', as the
Times front page suggests. I am worried by a wider trend that science is gradually being influenced by political views". == Global Warming Policy Foundation ==