Irvin was arrested in connection of killing 6 victims four separate incidents. This killing spree began December 2, 1954 and ended March 28, 1955. The crimes took place in
Vanderburgh and
Posey counties in Indiana and
Henderson county in Kentucky. The victims were: • December 2, 1954: Mary Holland, 33. Shot in head at close range at work. She was 3 months pregnant. Motive: Robbery. • December 23, 1954: Wesley Kerr, 29. Shot in head at close range at work. Robbery. • March 21, 1955: Wilhelmina Sailer, 47,
Mt. Vernon, Indiana. Housewife, killed at home. Shot in head. Burglary. • March 28, 1955: Goebel Duncan, 51.
Henderson, Kentucky. Burglary. • Raymond Duncan, 29, Goebel's son. • Maple Elizabeth Duncan, 20, Dorris Ray's (Raymond's brother) wife. In the last incident, Goebel's wife, Mamie, was shot, but survived, permanently blinded. Elizabeth had a two-year-old daughter who was spared. In connection with the confession they claimed to have extracted from Irvin, the police claimed he admitted to two dozen burglaries and robberies. It turns out that Irvin had a criminal history. He had received a sentence of 10 to 20 years for armed robbery in
Indianapolis in 1945, served 9 years, and moved to Evansville in May 1954. ==Capture==