Gaul was
indicted with first-degree murder, felony murder, tampering with evidence, stalking, reckless endangerment, possessing a firearm during a dangerous felony and theft between $500 and $1,000, in relation with the killing of Emma Walker.
Trial The trial started on April 30, 2018, On May 2, five friends of Walker testified about the day Gaul lied about being kidnapped. They also mentioned that Walker had sent them a text shortly before her killing, describing a man dressed in black who had been near her home. In the text, Walker said she was scared, and thought she was going to die. The defense attorney, Stone, did not deny that Gaul shot Walker, but argued that Gaul was trying to win her back as part of a series of ploys, which included faking his own kidnapping and attempting to pose as Walker's "rescuer".
Conviction On May 8, the jury found Gaul guilty of all charges. Judge McGee immediately sentenced Gaul to life in prison without the possibility of parole for 51 years.
Post-conviction In 2021, Gaul requested a new trial based on claims of
insufficient evidence, but the motion was denied. Gaul then
appealed to the
Tennessee Court of Criminal Appeals. In February 2023, the appellate judge ruled to uphold his murder conviction and modified the felony theft conviction. == Legacy ==