Hugh McIntyre of
Forbes found the song "decidedly sweeter and more restrained than his recent offerings", complimenting its ability to not "rely on big electro beats or any gimmicks to sell itself". He also praised Zayn for managing his
falsetto "as well as he has much grander performances in the past". Lauren O'Neill of
Noisey called the song an indication of "a mellower, more grown-up approach on album two", writing that it showcases "the strong upper part of Zayn's vocal range and falsetto". Writing for
Pitchfork in a review of
Icarus Falls,
Maura Johnston said Zayn's "ability to just barely pull off th[e] bodice-ripper-worthy" opening line, "Sweet baby, our sex has meaning", is a "sign of his skillful interpretative sense". Johnston also called it "a gorgeous opening, straddling the space between the breezy acousti-R&B that dominated the late '00s and the snare-heavy rhythms of modern trap-pop while also flaunting Zayn's falsetto".
Time listed it as the sixth worst song of 2018, describing it as "defanged" and "vapid", the melody as "forgettable", and the verses as "cringe-worthy". ==Credits and personnel==