Ulil in his book
"Becoming Liberal Islam" rejects the types of religious interpretation that are not pluralist, or against democracy which he said potentially undermines Islamic thinking. Ulil Abshar candidly criticizes the
MUI has monopolized the interpretation of Islam in Indonesia. MUI
fatwas stating that Pluralism, Liberalism, and Secularism are misguided ideologies and
Ahmadiyah is out of Islam, have kindled Ulil's emotion. due to JIL's article which is considered an insult and distort the truth of religion.
Habib Rizieq mentions that Liberal Islam is a "
Plagiarist of thinking", because its ideas simply imitate the ideas of previous
orientalists who began the
reforms, especially in understanding and assessing Islam. According to Habib Rizieq, The Indonesian's Liberal Islam movement rants excitedly to the application of
Hermeneutics in the studies of the Qur'an. In fact, long before JIL resonating the matter, an
Assyrian reverend named
Alphonse Mingana (1881–1937), who was also a lecturer of Christian Theology at
Birmingham University, in his book "
Syriac Influence on The Style of The Koran" published in 1927 states: "It is time to criticize the text of the Qur'an, as we have done to the Aramaic Jewish
Torah and Greek Christian
bibles." In mid 2005,
FPI attacked JIL headquarters due to the fatwa. ==Founders==