Light was met with "mixed or average" reviews from critics. At
Metacritic, which assigns a weighted average rating out of 100 to reviews from mainstream publications, this release received an
average score of 53 based on 15 reviews.
AllMusic's David Jeffries saw the album as already better than
Youth thanks to David Kahne being able to deliver on Matisyahu's worldview mysticism and spiritual musicianship, concluding that "[W]hether using his voice as a whisper or as a giant call across nations, the depth of feeling comes through brilliantly, and if the musical soundscape isn't familiar, the empowering and sincere lyrics most definitely are. Add Kahne's instantly accessible production and
Light is not only a welcome surprise, but an album that matches his debut." Mikael Wood, writing for
Spin, said that "No longer content to be the world's foremost Hasidic reggae star — what an ingrate! — Matisyahu expands his sound […] punching up his earnest ruminations on faith and inspiration with sleek hip-hop beats and shiny pop-rock guitars." Chris Martins of
The A.V. Club commended Matisyahu for scaling back on the "fake patois" delivery and "outdated
P.O.D.-style metal-dub" that brought down
Youth but felt he "carries the curse of burying his true brilliance in too much pop schlock."
Rolling Stones
Christian Hoard found Matisyahu more professional throughout the record by incorporating various soundscapes but felt he gets "dragged into earnest tedium by good-natured platitudes ("I must find a road that leads where nobody goes") and hippie-soul moments". Matthew Cole of
Slant Magazine gave Matisyahu credit for pushing reggae conventions by exploring other genres but felt he lacked insightful ideas beyond "generic New Age sloganeering" and was hampered by the "stylistic shifts and production gimmicks" from his collaborators, saying that "
Light ends up with exciting moments, but few memorable songs." He later highlighted "Silence" for being "an affecting closer" that conveys "genuine reflection", concluding that: "If he could match that level of focus and sincerity in his more energetic cuts, Matisyahu could have a great album on his hands." ==Track listing==