Carty, her lawyers, and her supporters contend that she has been unjustly sentenced to death for a murder she did not commit.
Reprieve claims that her defense attorney did not present mitigating evidence. They assert that no scientific evidence exists that establishes that she was at the scene of the crime, although her fingerprints were found in the car containing the victim's body. Carty has claimed that she was framed by three men for her work as an
informant with the Drug Enforcement Administration. Carty stated that "it was too difficult just to kill me, so they hatched this plot." Anderson, Robinson, and Williams, the other co-defendants in the kidnapping and murder, were given prison terms, but none received the
death penalty after testifying against Carty.
Baker Botts, the
law firm handling Carty's appeal, have argued that her trial attorney, Jerry Guerinot, handled her
defense in an
incompetent manner. Michael Goldberg of Baker Botts accuses Guerinot, who never won a death penalty case over his entire career, of failing to call any witnesses who might have persuaded the jury that she did not deserve execution. In addition, they assert that Guerinot met with Carty for only a single 15 minute interview. Guerinot's co-counsel has disputed this. Carty also claims that she was interviewed without counsel being present on one occasion. ==US breach of international law==