For her Coach of the Year awards, Vollstedt was selected by the LPGA in 1986 and 1993. She was chosen by the
Women's Golf Coaches Association in 1989 and 1994. Vollstedt shared this award in 1995. Vollstedt was also the Coach of the Year for the Pac-12 Conference in 1989. She re-won this award consecutively between 1993 and 1995.
Southwest PGA gave her the 1999 Anser Award for "significant and impactful contributions to ... golf throughout the state of Arizona." WGCA presented her with the Gladys Palmer Meritorious Service Award in 2003. In 2016, Vollstedt was selected as the Pac-12 Conference Golf Coach of the Century. Vollstedt was inducted into the Women's Golf Coaches Association Coaches Hall of Fame during 1994 and the
International Women's Sports Hall of Fame during 2003. She was also named to the
Arizona Sports Hall of Fame in 2009 and the
Pac-12 Conference Hall of Honor in 2018. She entered the LPGA Professionals Hall of Fame during 2020. ==Personal life==