won an
Emmy for his performance in this episode. In its original American broadcast, "Lisa's Pony" finished 35th in the ratings for the week of November 4–10, 1991, with a
Nielsen rating of 13.8, equivalent to approximately 12.7 million viewing households. It was the highest-rated show on Fox that week. "Lisa's Pony" was released with the episode "
Treehouse of Horror II" on a
VHS collection in 1999, called
Best of the Simpsons. Homer's voice actor,
Dan Castellaneta, received a
Primetime Emmy Award for
Outstanding Voice-Over Performance in 1992 for his performance in the episode. Since airing, the episode has received positive reviews from television critics. Niel Harvey of
The Roanoke Times called the episode a "classic bit of Simpsonia," and
The Baltimore Sun Kevin Valkenburg named it one of the "truly classic"
The Simpsons episodes. The authors of the book ''I Can't Believe It's a Bigger and Better Updated Unofficial Simpsons Guide'',
Gary Russell and
Gareth Roberts, called the episode "good stuff" and praised the "nice flashbacks to Lisa as a baby". Cinema Blend's Bryce Wilson called "Lisa's Pony" one of the best Lisa episodes, and added that the only words to describe it are "funny as hell". Nate Meyers of Digitally Obsessed rated the episode a5 (of 5), praising it for its references to
The Godfather and
2001: A Space Odyssey which "film buffs will find uproarious". Meyers added that Homer's and Lisa's relationship is "the heart of the episode, showing Homer to be more than just a brute". The episode's reference to
The Godfather was named the seventh greatest film reference in the history of the show by
Total Film Nathan Ditum.
The Star-Ledger named this episode's reference to
2001: A Space Odyssey one of their favorite references to
Stanley Kubrick on
The Simpsons. Molly Griffin of
The Observer commented that "Lisa's Pony" is one of the third season's episodes that "make the show into the cultural force it is today". Bill Gibron of DVD Verdict said "Lisa's Pony" is a "priceless part" of the show because of its "meshing of old storylines with new experiences, combined with some of the best jokes in the series". Gibron gave the episode a perfect score of 100. DVD Movie Guide's Colin Jacobson, however, gave the episode a less positive review, commenting episodes "in which Homer has to redeem himself to others aren't a rarity, and 'Lisa's Pony' falls in the middle of that genre's pack. Homer's escapades at the Kwik-E-Mart definitely add life to the proceedings, and some of his other antics make the show good. I like 'Lisa's Pony' but don't consider it to offer a great program." According to Greg Suarez of The Digital Bits, "Lisa's Pony" is considered a fan favorite. In a list of the show's top 10 episodes, compiled by the webmaster of the fan site
The Simpsons Archive and published by
USA Today, this episode was listed in seventh place.
Paul Cantor, a professor of English at the
University of Virginia, utilized "Lisa's Pony" as an example that
The Simpsons does not promote negative morals and values, which some critics have criticized the show for. ==References==